Skip to main content
Lakemoor, Illinois neighborhood served by VanEtten Appraisal

CERTIFIED RESIDENTIAL APPRAISER · LAKEMOOR, IL

Lakemoor Spans Two Counties, Five School Districts, and Two Tax Regimes. Your Appraiser Needs to Know Which One Applies.

Lakemoor sits at the Lake-McHenry county line. Depending on exactly where your parcel sits, you pay taxes to a different county, appeal to a different Board of Review, and send your children to a different school. No two of those facts change your home's value, but all of them change how it has to be analyzed.

$265,500

Median Home Value

+1.61%

Year-Over-Year Appreciation

6,467

Population

2.18%

Effective Property Tax Rate

65.1%

Owner-Occupied Homes

What Makes the Lakemoor Market Different

Lakemoor grew 111% between 2000 and 2010, almost entirely through 2000s-era subdivisions built along the US Route 12 and Route 120 corridors. The village is essentially built out now. Population has been flat since 2010, and there are no major active development zones to speak of. The practical result is a market where all the housing stock is roughly the same age, the comp pool is the comp pool, and condition and maintenance are the primary value differentiators.

The older exception is the Lily Lake corridor. The 89-acre glacial lake on the village's eastern edge has a ring of older cottages, many of them seasonal in origin and converted to year-round use over several decades. These properties occupy a different market tier than the 2000s subdivisions. Lakefront lots on Lily Lake carry a real premium, though the small lake size and 10-horsepower motor limit moderate how far that premium runs relative to larger Chain O'Lakes properties. Morrison Park on the eastern shore provides public beach access, which creates a secondary amenity tier for non-lakefront parcels within walking distance.

Two counties, five school districts, one small lake, and a village that built out in a decade. The jurisdictional complexity is larger than the geography suggests.

When Lakemoor Homeowners Need an Appraisal

Property taxes in Lakemoor depend entirely on which county holds the parcel. Lake County parcels fall under Grant Township and the Lake County Board of Review; McHenry County parcels fall under McHenry Township and the McHenry County Board of Review. The first step in any Lakemoor tax appeal is confirming the correct jurisdiction before filing. At 2.43% effective on a Lake County parcel, the annual tax bill on a $265,500 home runs approximately $6,452. At McHenry's 2.18%, the same home pays roughly $5,788. A certified appraisal documenting market value and providing defensible comparable sales is the strongest evidence in either county's Board of Review process. VanEtten Appraisal handles tax appeal appraisals for both Lake County and McHenry County parcels in Lakemoor.

For pre-listing decisions, Lakemoor's flat appreciation (1.61% in 2024) and thin comp pool mean pricing errors are common. In a market that is not running hot, an overpriced listing sits. For divorce and estate appraisals, the valuation challenge in Lakemoor is the county split: two otherwise identical homes can produce different tax projections for buyers depending on which side of the line they occupy, and that affects market value in ways automated tools never capture. Lakemoor's median household income of $100,414 and 65% homeownership rate mean most residents have real equity at stake in these decisions.

Neighborhoods We Appraise in Lakemoor

The US Route 12 and Route 120 intersection is the village's primary commercial node, and the 2000s-era subdivisions spread outward from that corridor in multiple directions. These neighborhoods are largely undifferentiated in character: single-family detached on platted lots, similar construction era and finish quality, with value differences driven mostly by lot position, condition, and proximity to arterial noise. For appraisal purposes, the Fox River corridor running through the village adds flood zone exposure that requires FEMA FIRM verification on low-lying parcels.

The Lily Lake area on the eastern edge is the market's character exception. Lakefront and lake-access properties here range from older converted cottages to more recently updated year-round residences. The 89-acre lake with Morrison Park public beach creates the village's amenity anchor. Volo Bog State Natural Area sits roughly 1.5 miles east, and Moraine Hills State Park is about 3 miles south, both of which contribute to the area's appeal without direct value impact on individual parcels. VanEtten Appraisal serves Lakemoor from our McHenry office and covers the full Ring of Lakes region including Wauconda, Round Lake, and Fox Lake.

Waterfront view near Lily Lake in Lakemoor, IL, showing the Chain O'Lakes-area landscape
Open-water center of Volo Bog State Natural Area, a National Natural Landmark near Lakemoor, IL
The bog eye at Volo Bog State Natural Area, a preserved natural landmark minutes from Lakemoor, IL
Trail through Moraine Hills State Park near Lakemoor, IL, with natural lake scenery

Served by Our McHenry Office

Lakemoor is served by VanEtten Appraisal's McHenry office. We cover all of the surrounding communities and schedule inspections throughout the county.

Learn more about our McHenry Office
5403 Bull Valley Rd, McHenry, IL 60050

Home Appraisal FAQs for Lakemoor

Can't find your answer? Call us at (815) 201-1866.

Get Your Lakemoor Appraisal Started

Call us directly or fill out the easy form below. You'll hear back from us quickly.

  • Fast communication, real answers. No waiting around.
  • No obligation, just accurate information
  • Serving all of Northern Illinois from 4 locations
  • Reports accepted by all major lenders and courts
Prefer to call? (815) 201-1866

This is just an inquiry — no fees or commitments. We'll reach out to discuss your needs and provide a quote.